The Girl Who Died/The Woman Who Lived

Between Series 6 (32) and 8 (34) there were just three two parters and for series 9 (35) we have now had three two parters so it seems that with the series length reduced to an even number, Moffat has clued on that people want two parters and the previous two parters have been highly enjoyable and had lots of actions. The first part was written by Steven Moffat and Jamie Matthieson. Quite why it took two people to write this script alludes me. The set up for this episode is that the Doctor and Clara arrive on Earth in Viking times and the village they arrive just in time for an attack from the Mire. Things move along and then Ashildr dies and is bought back to live but the thing about the first episode is that it feels an awful lot like padding. It’s the sort of padding which would be seen during the classic era. At the end I just thought that a lot happened but nothing substantial happened.

The second episode is where all the interesting stuff starts to happen. Despite some nice performances, the story was ruined by Rory the lion popping up later in the episode as the main threat and someone that Me is working with.

This story was heavily billed because it featured Maisie Williams who is apparently well known because of her role in Game of Thrones. She is definetly better when she plays Me than Ashidr. Not quite convinced that Me is a good name for a character even though the explanation given was quite clever.

This story and the second episode in particular is very much a character piece because over the course of the two episodes not much happens. You could easily edit these two episodes into one. I think that the second episode tries to explore the idea that immortality is a curse is something that was explored (briefly) in The Five Doctors and also mentioned in School Reunion (2006). I think that its generally perceived that immortality isn’t the great thing that it could be.

One aspect of the second episode that I found good was that I didn’t miss Clara. It was about 15 minutes into the episode before I noticed she hadn’t appeared yet. I think that this shows how good Peter Capaldi was and how good Maisie Williams was. During their scenes together they were both on very good form.

One thing that still makes me chuckle is all the speculation about who Maisie Williams’ character was. Many thought it was Susan or maybe Jenny and it turns out that she was just a normal girl/woman and there wasn’t anything extra terrestrial about her is something that must have annoyed loads of people on Gallifrey Base. It was a relief that there was nothing special about her although for a while I did think that maybe she was Jenny but that didn’t last very long.

I did like the bit where the Doctor finally realises why he chose this face. It was a question he asked back in his first story and its because of the events from Fires of Pompeii when the Tenth Doctor leaves and then has a change of heart and goes back to save Capaldi’s character in that story. It’s not such a barmy idea because Romana second incarnation is based on Princess Astra so with this logic it means that Peter Davison’s Doctor based his sixth incarnation on Commander Maxil from Arc of Infinity.

This two parter is the weakest so far of the season and maybe even of Capaldi’s tenure on the show. There are bits that are quite good but as a two parter it isn’t very exciting.  I think that its because it moves too slowly and after four episodes. It took three people to write these two episodes and to be honest that’s too many. I think that Catherine Treganna had the stronger episode. It would be wrong for me not to acknowledge the directing because Ed Bazalgette did a very good job as he utilises the lovely locations that the story was being filmed in and the house that is used in the second part looked fantastic and the lighting was just perfect. It’s amusing to think that Bazalgette went from lead guitarist of The Vapors who had a hit with Turning Japanese and then ended up directing Doctor Who.

The NEXT TIME trailer shows that the Zygons return to Doctor Who. Typical, you wait nearly forty years for a Zygon story and then we get two in two years.